Now you're getting to the heart of the matter. One way to isolate the
core of the problem, to find out how to ask the right question, is to try a few examples.
Let's label the two trashcans as Can A and Can B, and suppose the
skateboard is in Can A (this assumption won't harm your reasoning. Why?)
Suppose you try the obvious and make your one question: in which can is
the skateboard?
This won't work at all. If the geek you ask happens to be the liar, you'll
be told Can B; otherwise, you'll be told Can A. Either way because
you don't know the identity of the liar the information is useless.
And that's it, the main obstacle. You have two possibilities for the liar
and only one question.
Before you go back, take a few minutes to think through a couple more
examples. Try to think of a way around this obstacle.
|